Beliefs and the fictional narrators

Matravers, Derek (1995). Beliefs and the fictional narrators. Analysis, 55(2) pp. 121–122.



In his book The Nature of Fiction (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1991) Greg Currie makes the following proposal concerning the contents of works of fiction: 'Fs(P)' is an abbreviation of 'P is true in fiction S', where P is some proposition and S is some work of fiction.

'Fs(P)' is true iff it is reasonable for the informed reader to infer that the fictional author of S believes that P. (p. 80)

In reading a fiction we engage in a make-believe, and the fictional author is that fictional character constructed within our make-believe whom we take to be telling us the story as known fact. Currie's view applies a general account of communication (the mechanism described by Grice) to understanding fiction. This is an advantage for a number of reasons, not least that the capacities I use to understand a novel do seem to be those I use in understanding written factual information. From what the fictional author 'says', we infer what he believes; reading a book is 'an exploration of the fictional author's belief structure' (p. 76). From this simple and plausible basis, Currie gives a convincing philosophical account of the nature of fiction. Convincing though the account is, it cannot be quite right.

Viewing alternatives


Public Attention

Altmetrics from Altmetric

Number of Citations

Citations from Dimensions

Item Actions